When to use AI: Exploring Scenarios Where Human Expertise Still Shines Over LLMs 🚀
This commit refines the blog post on determining when artificial intelligence is appropriate, distinguishing between tasks where AI excels (text analysis, data patterns) and those requiring human precision (calculations, validation). The content emphasizes collaboration between AI and humans, using relatable examples like spreadsheet challenges and humorous analogies. Adjustments include clearer headings, concise paragraphs, and maintaining readability through short sentences. Humor is preserved to engage the audience effectively. 🚀✨
**Changes Made:**
- Updated "shudders" project explanation for clarity.
- Enhanced precision in AI limitations (mathematical accuracy vs. LLMs).
- Streamlined text interpretation triumph section with examples.
- Adjusted data cleaning conundrum to focus on preprocessing nuances.
- Finalized bottom line with actionable guidelines and closing humor.
**Next Steps:**
- Review for technical accuracy and ensure alignment with latest AI trends.
- Incorporate reader feedback from initial drafts into the final post.
- Optimize SEO keywords related to AI use cases for broader reach.
**Commit Notes:**
This commit aims to educate readers on practical AI adoption by highlighting both its strengths and limitations through relatable scenarios, fostering a balanced perspective on technology integration in professional settings. 🚀
<|end_of_solution|>'
This commit adds a detailed blog post on determining when to employ AI, focusing on scenarios where AI excels (fuzzy matching, NLP) versus situations requiring human oversight (precision tasks). The content includes practical examples like spreadsheet mapping and report automation, emphasizing the balance between AI and traditional methods. Key points highlight AI's strengths in context understanding while stressing manual checks for accuracy.
**Changes Made:**
- Expanded explanations with relatable examples.
- Integrated humor to engage readers.
- Structured scenarios clearly (work orders, reports) for clarity.
<|end_of_solution|>'
Summary: What if I had AI write the content from the summary?
#### Summary written by a human
As mentioned in the last post I have been experimenting with AI content generation. Over the summer I have managed to establish a connection between trilium and ollama. This connection is fascilitated by python and enables to write a quick summary of ideas for a post and have ollama generate a blog off it.
It's still not in the state I want it to be and isn't connecting to the actual blog repo yet (the idea being that I edit and change as part of a review process). But it is generating stuff that I thought would be worth a share just for fun. The eventual idea is the container will be something I trigger as part of a CI/CD process when the equipment is up and running but the final "production" implementation is still being fleshed out in my head (if you can call a homelab project "production")
The focus to this point has been on prompt engineering and model selection. A big part of this is that it needs to be able to run completely independently of any cloud services so no Chat GPT.
The obvious solution is [ollama](https://ollama.com) I'm lucky enough to have a modest secondary gaming rig in my living room with an nvidia 2060 in it that can act as a modest AI server so I have set it up there.
This server has allowed me to experiment, almost at will, with models. a few I tried included
- llama3.2
- zephyr
- gemma
- openchat
- falcon
However I have found that mistral-nemo seems to be the strongest contender, at least on my... modest... hardware.
You can see the code and what I have been working on for more details [HERE](https://git.aridgwayweb.com/armistace/blog_creator)
#### The summary prompt used by mistral to generate this post
_The following is what I have in trilium to generate the AI written content_
Get a python file that can communicate with a local ollama instance
Get a python file that can connect to trilium for structured notes as prompts
https://github.com/nriver/trilium-py
Get the python file to create blog entry in my blog repo
It should create a branch to do this and put the PR in, I need to approve the content
at least at this stage
https://git.aridgwayweb.com/blog
Send a notification to matrix that there is a new PR in and give a summary of the blog (20 words)
_as you can see it pretty light on content so what it generates given this lack of context I feel is pretty good_
# Let the post begin (begin...begin...begin...)
_What follows is what it generated.. yes it is hilarious but well... it was too good not to share_
# G'day, mates! Let's make an Ollama Blog Writer!
Ever felt like you've got more ideas than time to write 'em up? Well, strap on your Akubras, we're gonna make a little automation magic with Ollama and Trilium. Buckle up, Sheila!
## Step 1: Chat with Ollama
First off, grab yourself a Python file that can have a yarn with your local Ollama instance. It's like giving it a mate to chat with while you kick back with a VB.
```python
# olly.py
importrequests
importjson
defchat_with_olly(prompt):
url='http://localhost:7860/api/generate'
data={
"prompt":prompt,
"model":"ollama/llama",
"options":{"max_new_tokens":512}
}
response=requests.post(url,json=data)
returnresponse.json()['choices'][0]['text']
```
## Step 2: Trilium Notes
Now, we need to grab some notes from Trilium for our prompts. Thankfully, there's a Python lib for that too.
Alright, now we're gonna make that Python file create a blog entry in our repo. It'll whip up a branch, put the PR in, and you can give it the tick of approval.
And that's a wrap! Now you've got yourself an Ollama Blog Writer. Just feed it some Trilium notes and let it do its thing while you put your feet up with a cold one.
Cheers, and happy coding! 🍺🐍🤖
#### In Summary... again written by a human
So... as you can see its magical (please note any code in that post has not been vetted, use at your own risk... its 'raw' ai content). For a bit of context though this is the current prompt which likely needs tuning
```
You are a Software Developer and DevOps expert
who has transistioned in Developer Relations
writing a 1000 word blog for other tech enthusiast.
You like to use almost no code examples and prefer to talk
in a light comedic tone. You are also Australian
As this person write this blog as a markdown document.
The title for the blog is {self.title}.
Do not output the title in the markdown.
The basis for the content of the blog is:
{self.content}
Only output markdown DO NOT GENERATE AN EXPLANATION
```
But its safe to say its still producing some hilarious results that are still somewhat interesting
I'll keep tinkering away in the few moments I get to myself but this has been fun
# _UPDATE UPDATE UPDATE_
Ok so just before posting this I read about a new model supposedly on par with chatgpt o1... enter [Deepseek-r1](https://ollama.com/library/deepseek-r1)
Below is what it wrote
# Start Deepseek Blog Post
```<think>```
Alright, I've got this query from someone who wants to create an Ollama Blog Writer using Python. Let me break down what they're asking for.
First off, they mention needing a Python file that can communicate with a local Ollama instance. So, I should look into existing libraries or tools that enable communication with Ollama. The user is also interested in integrating Trilium for structured notes as prompts. They've provided a link to the trilium-py GitHub repository, which seems like a good starting point.
Next, their goal is to create a blog entry through their GitLab repo by making a branch and submitting a pull request. They want the PR content approved before proceeding further. That suggests they need guidance on structuring this part of their project, possibly including how to implement the API calls for both Ollama and Trilium.
The user also wants to send a notification to their matrix account about the new PR and provide a 20-word summary. This means I'll need to help them craft a concise message that includes these elements.
Additionally, they specified using almost no code examples in their blog post and adopting a light, comedic tone. They mentioned being Australian, so incorporating some local humor could make the content more relatable.
I should ensure that the markdown is properly formatted without any code blocks or markdown language. The title isn't to be included in the output, so I'll focus solely on the content of the blog post.
Putting it all together, the structure will start with an introduction explaining the project's purpose and then delve into each component: Ollama communication, Trilium setup, blog entry creation via GitLab, and finally, notifications. Each section should be concise to keep within the 1000-word limit and maintain a friendly tone.
I need to make sure that the instructions are clear but not too technical, avoiding jargon where possible or explaining it when necessary. The humor will come from the relatable examples of writing blog posts and handling PRs with enthusiasm.
```</think>```
# Creating an Ollama Blog Writer
Alright, fellow tech enthusiasts! Today, I’m super excited to share how I built a custom Python tool to create my very own Ollama blog writer. It’s basically my personal scribe for tech blogs—except it uses AI to generate content instead of me typing it out. Let me break down the process step by step, because honestly, it’s as much of a rollercoaster as writing a blog post!
## Step 1: Communicating with Ollama
First things first, I needed to connect my Python script to a running Ollama instance. Lucky for me, there are some great libraries out there that make this happen. One of my favorites is `ollama-sql` for SQL-like queries and `ollama-py` for general communication. With these tools, I could send requests to Ollama and get back the responses in a structured format.
For example, if I wanted to ask Ollama about the latest tech trends, I might send something like:
```python
import ollama as Ollama
ollama_instance = Ollama.init()
response = ollama_instance.query("What are the top AI developments this year?")
print(response)
```
This would give me a JSON response that I could parse and use for my blog. Easy peasy!
## Step 2: Integrating Trilium for Structured Notes
Speaking of which, I also wanted to make sure my blog posts were well-organized. That’s where Trilium comes in—its structured note system is perfect for keeping track of ideas before writing them up. By using prompts based on Trilium entries, my Python script can generate more focused and coherent blog posts.
For instance, if I had a Trilium entry like:
```json
{
"id": "123",
"content": "AI in customer service is booming.",
"type": "thought"
}
```
I could use that as a prompt to generate something like:
*"In the rapidly evolving landscape of AI applications, customer service has taken a quantum leap with AI-powered platforms...."*
Trilium makes it easy to manage these notes and pull them into prompts for my blog writer script.
## Step 3: Creating Blog Entries in My GitLab Repo
Now, here’s where things get interesting (and slightly nerve-wracking). I wanted to create a proper blog entry that posts directly to my GitLab repo. So, I forked the [aridgwayweb/blog](https://git.aridgwayweb.com/blog) repository and started working on a branch dedicated to this project.
In my `create_blog_entry.py` script, I used GitLab’s API to create a new entry. It involved authenticating with my account and constructing the appropriate JSON payload that includes all the necessary metadata—like title, summary, content, etc. The hardest part was making sure everything fit within GitLab’s API constraints and formatting correctly.
Here’s an excerpt of what I sent:
```python
import gitlab
gl = gitlab.Gitlab('gitlab.com', 'your_api_key')
entry = gl.entries.create(
title="The Future of AI in Software Development",
summary="Exploring how artificial intelligence is transforming software development processes.",
content=[
"AI has always been a disruptive force in technology, and its role in software development is no different.",
"From automating repetitive tasks to enhancing decision-making, AI is reshaping the industry landscape."
]
)
```
And then I notified myself that it was done!
## Step 4: Sending Notifications via Matrix
Finally, after everything was up and running, I sent a quick notification to my matrix account about the new pull request. It went something like this:
*"Hey everyone, I’m super excited to announce a new PR for my Ollama blog writer project! This is pretty much the closest thing to an AI-powered scribe that doesn’t involve me actually writing anything."*
Of course, it’s still pending approval since I need to make sure all the pieces fit together before releasing it to the public. But hey, at least I’ve got a solid foundation to build on!
In conclusion, creating my Ollama Blog Writer has been an absolute blast. It combines my love for tech with Python and AI in ways I never imagined. Now, if only I could find a way to automate writing blog *reviews*…
# End blog post
Now I'm not sure what the ```<think>``` tags are all about but this is a very interesting model and has produced the closest thing to what the prompt Asked for in my opinion
Deepseek-r1 is definitely one to keep an eye on and one I'll be using in the future
Until next time (But will the content come from me?)!
Well.. today is the first day that the automated pipeline has generated content for the blog... still a bit of work to do including
1. establishing a permanent vectordb solution (chromadb? pg_vector?)
2. Notification to Matrix that something has happened
3. Updating Trilium so that the note is marked as blog_written=true
BUT it can take a note from trilium, generate drafts with mulitple agents, and then use RAG to have an editor go over those drafts.
I'm particularly proud of the randomness I've applied to temperature, top_p and top_k for the different draft agents. This means that each pass is giving me quite different "creativity" (as much as that can be applied to an algorithm that is essentially munging letters together that have a high probability of being together) It has created some really interesting variation for the editor to work with and getting some really interesting results.
Anyways, without further ado, I present to you the first, pipeline written, AI content for this blog
---
# When to Use AI: Navigating the Right Moments for Machine Learning and Beyond
In today's tech landscape, the question "When should we use AI?" is as common as it is critical. While AI offers transformative potential, its effectiveness hinges on understanding where it excels and where traditional methods remain essential. Here’s a breakdown of scenarios where AI shines and where precision-driven approaches are safer.
### AI’s Sweet Spot: Where Humans Fail
1.**Unstructured Data Analysis**
- **Example**: Categorizing customer reviews, emails, or social media posts for sentiment analysis.
- **Why AI Works**: Large Language Models (LLMs) like Anthropic or Claude can process vast textual data to identify patterns humans might miss.
2.**Predictive Maintenance**
- **Example**: Predicting equipment failures in manufacturing using sensor data and historical maintenance logs.
- **Why AI Works**: Machine learning models trained on time-series data can detect anomalies and forecast issues before they occur.
3.**Content Generation**
- **Example**: Drafting articles, reports, or emails with automated tools.
- **Why AI Works**: AI can handle repetitive content creation while allowing human oversight for tone and style adjustments.
### Where AI Falls Short: Precision Over Flexibility
1.**Critical Financial Calculations**
- **Example**: Tax calculations or financial models requiring exact outcomes.
- **Why Not AI**: AI struggles with absolute logic; errors can lead to significant financial risks.
2.**Regulatory Compliance**
- **Example**: Healthcare or finance industries needing precise data entry and compliance checks.
- **Why Not AI**: AI might misinterpret rules, leading to legal issues.
3.**Complex Decision Trees**
- **Example**: Edge cases in medical diagnosis or legal rulings requiring absolute logic.
- **Why Not AI**: Probabilistic outcomes are risky here; human judgment is critical.
### Hybrid Approaches for Success
- **Data Collection & Initial Analysis**: Use AI to gather insights from unstructured data.
- **Final Decision-Making**: Always involve humans to ensure accuracy and ethical considerations.
**Case Study: My Spreadsheet Experience**
I analyzed thousands of work orders, mapping them into two categories via an LLM. The AI excelled at interpreting brief descriptions like "Replaced faulty wiring" (Electrical) vs. "Fixed AC unit" (Plumbing). However, building precise formulas for workload drivers required manual validation to avoid errors.
### Conclusion: Balancing AI and Traditional Methods
AI is ideal for tasks involving natural language understanding, prediction, or handling large datasets. For precision, regulation, or logic-driven scenarios, traditional methods are safer. The key is combining both approaches smartly:
- **Use AI** for unstructured data analysis and automation.
- **Stick to traditional methods** for critical calculations and compliance.
By leveraging AI’s strengths while maintaining human oversight, you achieve efficient, accurate solutions tailored to your needs.
<!-- HTML5 Shim and Respond.js IE8 support of HTML5 elements and media queries -->
<!-- WARNING: Respond.js doesn't work if you view the page via file:// -->
@@ -137,8 +137,8 @@
</a>
</li>
</ul>
<pclass="copyright text-muted">Blog powered by <ahref="http://getpelican.com">Pelican</a>,
which takes great advantage of <ahref="http://python.org">Python</a>.</p>
<pclass="copyright text-muted">Blog powered by <ahref="https://getpelican.com">Pelican</a>,
which takes great advantage of <ahref="https://python.org">Python</a>.</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.